I just finished doing a 52 page beta read. Yesterday, I talked to my BP, and told him I was about 25 pages into it, and had 40 or so comments. He sounded a little upset by that.
I finished it today, with 82 comments, and a one page synopsis of my thoughts. Afterwards, I was thinking about him sounding upset. And it got me thinking… Do I overdo it?
I know when I get a beta-read back of my own work, there is nothing more disappointing than only a few comments. Especially if they are general and of no value. I pour my heart into my beta reads, and really think over everything, and I comment on the good, as well as making suggestions if I don’t think something reads smoothly. The better a novel is, the more comments I make… It just seems worth the effort.
(And let me tell you, this particular novel is worth the effort. It has BEST SELLER stamped all over it.)
I’m wondering, though… is this too much?
If it were me, and I was about to submit to a publisher, I would want to know EVERY little hiccup in my story. Fix my spacing, correct my punctuation, tell me my voice is off… as well as the “Oh! This is really good” remarks.
I’m wondering though, is that what everyone wants?
What do you want in a beta read?




